The Meals and Drug Administration is contemplating banning the meals dye referred to as Crimson No. 3. It is utilized in sweet, snacks and soda. An FDA spokesman says a choice might come “quickly”.
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
The Meals and Drug Administration is reviewing a petition to ban a meals dye referred to as Crimson No. 3. It has been used for many years in 1000’s of merchandise, perhaps together with some you have eaten – sweet, chips, yogurt, soda. However client teams and researchers query the well being results. An FDA spokesperson tells NPR a choice might come quickly. So NPR’s Allison Aubrey has us prepared. Allison, good morning.
ALLISON AUBREY, BYLINE: Good morning, Steve. Nice to be right here.
INSKEEP: What might probably go unsuitable with a meals product with the enticing identify Crimson Dye No. 3?
AUBREY: Properly, Crimson Dye 3 is a petroleum-based meals additive. It has been used for over 50 years to offer meals that vibrant, flashy coloring. It was as soon as utilized in cosmetics too, Steve, however again in 1990 the FDA banned it after lab research confirmed it might trigger most cancers in animals at excessive doses. Now, the FDA beforehand concluded Crimson 3 is secure for folks within the doses they’re uncovered to in meals, sweet, drinks.
However final yr, the state of California handed a legislation aiming to ban the usage of Crimson 3, pointing to proof that artificial meals dyes could exacerbate habits issues in youngsters.
INSKEEP: Wow. A connection to the habits of youngsters – prefer it’s – what? – a psychoactive drug? Is that what we’re saying right here?
AUBREY: You recognize, it has been very tough to evaluate the affect on youngsters’ habits. Consider all of the issues youngsters eat in a day, all of the components that may affect their habits. So to suss out a selected impact of dyes hasn’t been straightforward.
INSKEEP: Proper.
AUBREY: However there’s a honest quantity of analysis, Steve, and California officers really reviewed about 25 research. Greater than half pointed to a optimistic affiliation, displaying meals dyes could contribute to signs resembling inattention, hyperactivity. Different research discovered no affiliation. So it was a blended bag. Earlier this yr, the California governor signed one other legislation to ban a gaggle of artificial dyes at school meals, together with purple, inexperienced and yellow dyes. However Crimson 3 is the one dye within the petition at present earlier than the FDA.
INSKEEP: Does this imply the FDA might ban this dye the best way that California did?
AUBREY: Sure. The FDA petition is in search of to get rid of Crimson 3 solely from the meals provide. Shopper teams argue there’s sufficient proof. And I am going to level out, it will be tough to conduct new research to show a type of trigger and impact between meals dyes and worsening habits. I imply, what mother or father, given what’s already recognized about artificial meals dyes, would signal their child up for such a research?
I spoke to Thomas Galligan of the Middle for Science within the Public Curiosity. That is the group that has petitioned the FDA. He says there isn’t a purpose so as to add these artificial dyes to meals.
THOMAS GALLIGAN: Crimson 3, like each meals dye, solely serves as a advertising instrument for the meals trade. It is simply there to make meals look visually interesting so that buyers wish to spend their cash on it.
AUBREY: He factors out that Crimson 3 has been banned or severely restricted in lots of international locations, together with within the European Union, Australia and Japan.
INSKEEP: So what does the meals trade do in the event that they lose it right here?
AUBREY: Properly, we reached out to the Nationwide Confectioners Affiliation, which represents sweet makers. A spokesperson there tells us they’re ready for the FDA to conclude its overview earlier than commenting, however they are saying the trade is dedicated to meals security and that its merchandise are made utilizing solely FDA-approved elements. I am going to say the meals trade has proven that it may pivot to extra pure alternate options.
About 10 years in the past, when Kraft Meals determined to take artificial dyes out of that vibrant orange mac and cheese, they changed them with colours from spices, resembling paprika and turmeric.
INSKEEP: Allison, thanks a lot.
AUBREY: Thanks, Steve.
INSKEEP: Tasty reporting from NPR’s Allison Aubrey.
Copyright © 2024 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its remaining kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could fluctuate. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.